Knee Pain: When Physiotherapy Is Enough and When Surgery Is Needed

IMED German Clinic - Traumatología en Marbella

Table of Contents

When is physiotherapy enough for knee pain?

In most cases the first step is treatment without surgery: guided exercise, physiotherapy, weight control, adjusting activity and, if needed, pain medication. Many knee problems improve this way, especially those linked to wear and tear (osteoarthritis), pain around the kneecap or tendon problems.

Surgery is considered when non-surgical treatment is not enough or when there is an injury that will not heal on its own. To know where you stand, the first step is an assessment with an examination and, if appropriate, an X-ray or MRI.

What causes knee pain?

The most common causes are:

  • Osteoarthritis: wear of the cartilage, with pain when walking, climbing stairs or after rest.
  • Meniscus tear: pain, clicking or locking, from a sudden twist or from age-related wear.
  • Ligament injury, such as the anterior cruciate ligament: usually after an injury or a twist, with a feeling of instability.
  • Patellofemoral pain: discomfort at the front of the knee, typical when running or going downstairs.
  • Tendinitis and bursitis: inflammation from overload or repeated movements.

Each cause is treated differently, which is why it is important to identify it before deciding on treatment.

What does non-surgical treatment involve?

Conservative treatment can include:

  • Physiotherapy and exercises to strengthen the thigh and stabilise the knee.
  • Weight loss when overweight, because it reduces the load on the joint.
  • Suitable footwear and adapted activity, avoiding movements that trigger the pain.
  • Medication prescribed by the doctor to control pain and inflammation.
  • Injections, when the orthopedic surgeon considers them appropriate in a specific case.

For degenerative meniscus tears, for example, several studies have shown that physiotherapy can give results comparable to surgery in many patients.

When is knee surgery considered?

An orthopedic surgeon may consider an operation in situations such as these:

  • Mechanical locking of the knee, which cannot be fully straightened or bent.
  • Instability from torn ligaments, especially if you play sport or your job is physically demanding.
  • Meniscus or cartilage tears that cause mechanical symptoms and do not improve with treatment.
  • Fractures and serious injuries after an accident.
  • Advanced osteoarthritis with severe pain that limits daily life and does not respond to other treatments: in that case a knee replacement may be considered.

The decision is always individual, based on your symptoms, your tests and your goals. To learn more about replacements, you can read how long a knee or hip replacement lasts.

When should you see a doctor straight away?

Seek an assessment without waiting if you notice any of these signs:

  • You cannot put weight on the leg after a blow or a fall.
  • The knee is very swollen, misshapen or has locked.
  • A red, hot, swollen knee, especially with fever.
  • Pain and swelling in the calf, which may point to a circulation problem.
  • Severe pain at night or pain that does not improve after several weeks.

With fever, calf pain or difficulty breathing, go to the emergency department.

How can German Clinic Marbella help?

The orthopedics and traumatology team at German Clinic Marbella assesses knee pain, guides non-surgical treatment and, when needed, considers surgery. Dr. Ignatios Chatziandreou performs knee and hip replacements, including custom 3D-printed implants, and revision surgery.

Frequently asked questions

Does knee pain go away on its own?

Some mild pain caused by overload improves with relative rest and exercise. If the pain lasts more than a few weeks, keeps coming back or comes with swelling, locking or instability, it is worth having an orthopedic surgeon assess it.

How long should I try physiotherapy before thinking about surgery?

There is no single time frame. Non-surgical treatment is usually tried for several weeks or months, unless there is locking, marked instability or a serious injury that needs treating sooner. The orthopedic surgeon decides in each case.

What tests are needed to study the knee?

First, a clinical examination. Depending on the case, an X-ray is requested, which shows the bone and the wear, or an MRI, which shows the meniscus, ligaments and cartilage.

Is a meniscus tear always operated on?

No. Many tears, especially degenerative ones, improve with physiotherapy. Surgery is considered when there is locking or mechanical symptoms that do not improve, or in specific traumatic injuries.

When is a knee replacement considered?

When there is advanced osteoarthritis with severe pain that limits daily life and other treatments have not been enough. It is always assessed individually.

Do you speak English and German?

Yes. The German Clinic Marbella team sees patients in Spanish, English, German, Greek, Norwegian, Italian, Hungarian and Russian, among other languages.

Where is German Clinic Marbella and how do I book an appointment?

German Clinic Marbella is at C/ Jacinto Benavente, 10, 29601 Marbella, Málaga, in the city centre, open Monday to Friday, 08:30 to 18:00. You can book by phone (+34 951 413 103), WhatsApp (+34 637 806 085), email (info@german-clinic.com) or through the contact form.

Conclusion

Knee pain that drags on deserves an assessment. Often it settles without surgery, and when an operation is needed it should be based on a clear diagnosis and a well-reasoned indication.

At German Clinic Marbella, Dr. Ignatios Chatziandreou assesses knee pain and decides with you on the most suitable treatment. You can book an appointment here or call +34 951 413 103.

The clinic is at C/ Jacinto Benavente, 10, 29601 Marbella, Málaga, in the centre of Marbella.

Last updated: November 2026. This article is for information only and does not replace a medical consultation.